LIGHTING UP THE TOWN, cont'd...

Medina Square Light posts. These decorative historic looking lamp posts were replaced in 2015.
Photo taken 12 June 2019.

The research into the history of bringing electricity to Medina continues as I scour the newspaper microfilm to tease out snippets of news on the topic.So far, I have browsed 2 ½ years of The Gazette, out of a possible of 6 years. My search has been concentrated on 1892, when we know the light and power scheme was first proposed, and 1897 when we know that the light company finally started operations.

Some interesting things I have learned along the way:

1. When the village of Medina first started talking about bringing electricity to the village, it was always only with the thought to light the streets and businesses and private residences. There was no thought to bring in electricity to power homes and businesses. And why would there be? In 1897, homes were not filled with electrical appliances as they are today. Businesses used gas powered motors and dynamos to power their machinery.

2. Strangely, the power company never seemed to promote itself. I have yet to find an ad.

3. Most of the Medina County news came in the form of “letters” or articles sent in by correspondents from each of the villages and crossroads of the area. But the village of Medina did not have a separate correspondent as it was the home of The Gazette. Its local news was in the Local News and Personals columns of the paper, that usually appeared on pages 4 or 5.

4. Medina Village Council meetings were generally not deemed worthy of news print.

5. Prior to electric lights, Medina Public Square was lit by gas lamps.

This ad for electric fans appeared in the
Akron Beacon Journal 23 July 1896 p. 4 

Here is a timeline of events, as I have been able to reconstruct them:

1892

• 3 March – “Medina behind its neighbors” Mr Fred Bostwick of Thomson-Houston Electric answered many questions
• 10 March – finances of electric light plant

This excerpt shows the estimated cost of the electric plant.
Medina Gazette 3 Mar 1892 p.4 

• 10 March – a new stove plant in Medina is dependent on the light plant
• 16 March  – Ohio legislature passed an act, that while it did not name Medina, targeted Medina specifically, to allow the village council to issue bonds and levy a tax for the purchase and erection of an electric light plant.
• 17 March – editorial urging a yes vote for the lights
• 31 March – “example” lights set up by AI Root plant and run by his dynamo
• 7 April – slander is that village council members don’t pay taxes; lists taxes for T. Ferriman, J.S. Warner , W.H. Hobart, D. Hemmeter, W.B. Croft, R.S. Shepard
• 7 April – Dr. S. Hudson writes letter criticizing the electric lights scheme as too precipitous (and by waiting they could save half the cost), too experimental, that the village already had capital improvement debts totaling over $20,000, and that streets and sidewalks should be improved first.
• 12 April – new village council has a “Street Lights & Lighting” committee consisting of Hobart, Ferriman & Warner
• 14 April – Vote on electric lights passed with 70% of the vote. AI Root workers and other factor workers marched en masse to polling booths.

Election Results Medina Gazette 14 Apr 1892 p.6 

• 12 May – No electric lights this year; Herman Holmes filed suit against village council to prevent them from selling electric lights bonds; lawyer Spellman; be to be heard by Judge Nye (from Elyria)
• 19 May – Holmes suit claims that the price quoted by village council $18000 was way too expensive and should be able to be accomplished for half that price; and that the legislation passed to allow the village to issue bonds and taxes was unconstitutional.
• 21 July – J.M. Henderson, attorney for Village Council, asked to remove his previous filing and to be able to file a separate action by 15 Aug.; probably abandon of litigation & repeal of electric light ordinance recently passed by the Council; Medina will remain dark this coming winter.
• NO OTHER ARTICLES COULD BE FOUND IN THE INTERVENING MONTHS
• 22 Dec – Monies set aside in bank for the proposed stove factory sit idle because stove plant didn’t open because of NO ELECTRICITY.

1896 - October through December newspapers have been searched with no articles found mentioning the light and power company. However, 1896 was a very busy year:

• Medina was building a new waterworks plant.
• The Methodist Episcopal Church that was built in 1859 burned down. The women of church went into a flurry of fundraising.
• There was a lot of discussion of the electric railways that were being proposed for Medina.
• W.W. Pancoast, who had embezzled a great deal of money from the people of Medina, was arrested elsewhere on charges of murder. People followed his trial and sentencing closely.
• The Gazette had a weekly column dedicated to the care, maintenance and proper use of the bicycles that had become very popular.
• Several gentleman waged a war in the newspaper on whether bicycles should be allowed on the sidewalks.
• William McKinley was running for President of the United States. As an Ohio man, and a Republican, The Gazette dedicated a great deal of space in its papers boosting and endorsing McKinley and vilifying his opponent, William Jennings Bryan. McKinley won and the paper crowed about the victory. After being elected to his second term as President in 1900, McKinley was assassinated in 1901.

1897 - The October through December 1896 and January and February of 1897 newspaper microfilm was scoured, but nothing mentioned bringing electricity to Medina. But... 

• 13 March – Ozro Sanders granted franchise for erection of an electric light plant to be in operation inside of six months

Medina Gazette 11 Mar 1897 p.5

and from the big city paper...

Plain Dealer 13 March 1897 P.9

• 8 April – Electric bells have been put up in both the recitation rooms at the High school building. Powered by what?
• 22 April - attention to better street lighting; parties interested in obtaining a franchise at $1600-$2500 a year;deemed too expensive previous year spend $38 for lighting (from what source?); could add to water works; hope for Medina to enjoy lighting in the “not-distant time”
• WHAT CHANGED? WHEN? 
• 13 May – “when the electric lights brighten the streets (of) Medina”
• 27 May “Medina is…putting in electric lights”
• 27 May – Mrs. Sanders is purchasing materials; predict lights within 60 days; lot is purchase west of the N O depot; credit to Mr. O. Sanders for “taking hold” of this business for our town
• 8 July – Chimney and foundation in place
• 15 July – work of hanging the electric light cable was completed
• 12 Aug – engine, pump, heater & separator in position for electric light plant; cementing the floor has begun; already have orders for 500 incandescent lamps & 20 arc lamps; lighting for new Methodist church in place
• 2 Sep – dynamo arrived; expected that lights on during fair week

And finally...

• 16 Sep – engine of Medina Electric Light and Power Company started up; eight business houses had been equipped with lamps 7 4 arc lights, one on each corner of the park, illuminated the streets; soon most of businesses 7 private residences will be lighted by electricity;
• 30 “light there be light and there was light and the people rejoiced greatly”

Medina Gazette 30 Sep 1897 p. 5

1905 – Judge Fremont O. Phllips bought the Medina Electric light and Power Company

1915 – Company bought by Pennsylvania Power Company who sold it to Cleveland Southwestern Power Company who sold it to Western Reserve Light and Powere Company

1931 –Sold to Ohio Edison

And as much as I would like to track down exactly when Medina village council took up the lighting and power issue again, I cannot justify the amount of time it would take to do so.

By the way, Dr. Hudson, who wrote the article criticizing Medina for wanting to install an electric plant in 1892 was right about one item. The price for building and operating the plant had dropped by almost 50% when the council took up the plan again in 1897!

Sources:

Medina Gazette

Historical Highlights of Medina(1966)

"Beyond the Storefronts" Medina Square http://www.medinasquare.org/  by Bob Hyde

Medina County Coming of Age by Joanne King
Summit County Beacon 18 May 1892 page 8
Akron Beacon Journal 18 1897 p. 5
Akron Beacon Journal 23 July 1896 p. 4
Plain Dealer 13 March 1897 p.9

Lighting up the Town

Last week's post on Memorial Day in Medina featured a lot of pictures of the parades around the Square. There was a marked difference in the photos pre-1900 as opposed to after that date. Did you notice?

Medina Square 1889

Medina Square circa 1897

Do you see it now?

Sometime in the intervening years, Medina installed electricity. Didn't really impact last week's blog, but it put that little kernel of curiosity in my brain. Exactly WHEN did Medina get electricity?

{Some of the lines are also telephone lines.}

Bob Hyde's website Beyond the Storefronts is a great place to start off place when researching any  history surrounding the Medina Square. And since he installed a search function, VOILA! Anything I want to find, I can. And I did!

Bob had this picture of the Power Generating Station, and accompanying history about its location at 121 West Smith Road.

According to Bob:

"#121 West Smith Road:

Medina Electric Light and Power Generating Plant, Albert G. Oatman and Ozro Sanders, Props.   (1897-1905)

1.  Albert G. Oatman and Ozro Sanders under the company title of the Medina Electric Light and Power Company have erected substantial brick structure equipped with necessary machinery, power, and dynamos for supplying the town with arc and incandescent lights and power.

2.  The plant was put into operation on September 15, 1897 and already there are 800 incandescent lights supplied to stores, offices, residences and shops in the village.

3.  The rates in effect are reasonable and range from one to five lights furnished for 60 cents each, per month; from five to fifteen at 50 cents and from fifteen to twenty-five lights at 40 cents each, per month.

4.  The Company is equipped for furnishing arc lights for streets, but as for now no contract has been made with the village.  In a few places lights have been provided on a private subscription basis

5.  The plant is equipped with one K. W. generator, one 125 horsepower engine and one 150 horse power boiler, the largest in the town.

6.  Simon S. Oatman bought out A. G. Oatman’s interest in 1905.

Phillips Electric Generating Plant, Judge F. O. Phillips, Prop. (1905-1915)

1.  S. S. Oatman sold Medina Electric Light and Power on Lot 16 to F. O. Phillips for $14,000 in 1905.

Pennsylvania Power Co., Cleveland Southwestern Power Co., Western Reserve Light andPower Co. (1915-1931)

1.  Judge F. O. Phillips sold Phillips Electric to Charles A. Moore of Chicago in 1915.

So, from this information, it looks like Medina got electricity in 1897. 

The Medina Electric and Light Company West Smith Road
Circa 1900-1915

Bob's history on the short lived company seems pretty complete. But is it everything that can be found? Probably, because Bob is an excellent historian.

But to make sure that is ALL the information available about the company, I need to do more research. That is called due diligence.

This cutout is from the 1897 Sanborn Fire Insurance Maps, a database available from within the library. The earlier Sanborn maps, for 1885 and 1892, don't show any kind of power plant.The  Power Company, circled in red, is near the corner of Elmwood and Smith Road. It was there early enough that it could be included in the publication for 1897. But does it predate 1897??

Joann King's excellent book on 19th
century Medina County. 

Joann King, another excellent historian, wrote Medina County Coming of Age 1810-1900. And she has a lot more to say about the beginnings of electrical power in Medina:

"In Medina, council gave Ozro Sanders the first utility franchise to build an electric plant. Individual industries already had their own dynamos used primarily to power machinery, [A.I. Root was one such company] but this company was solely for the benefit of the private subscriber. Sander's first order was for 150 individual lights, 125 were to go into the Phoenix Block. In 1898, this company officially became Medina Electric Light and Power under the leadership of A.G. Oatman and Sanders. In one year, they had 800 light bulbs shining in offices, stores, and homes."  p. 471

It doesn't give the date that the council gave the franchise to Sanders, just the date that the company was named.

Later in the book:

"In 1892, the Ohio Legislature passed a bill allowing Medina Council to hold an election for the purpose of levying the residents 2 mils for electric lights... Voters approved the light plant 355 to 166." And in the next paragraph:

"O. Sanders started building Medina's first electric plant on the northwest side of town near the depot... Three months later he had 500 subscriptions for incandescent lamps and an order from the village for twenty arc street lamps. Medina Council installed four of those lamps in November..."

Slowly lights began to appear around town. In 1897, the Medina Electric Light and Power Company started its engine and nineteenth century life in Medina was a thing of reality."

It still isn't clear when Medina got electricity. Here is what we have learned:

•  In 1892, the Ohio Legislature passed a bill so that city council could put a levy on the ballot for citizens to be taxed for electric lights. And the levy passed.
• When did the Ohio Legislature pass the bill?
• When did the citizens get to vote on the levy?
• Ozro Sanders won the franchise to build the first electric plant. 
• When did city council award the franchise to Sanders?
• When exactly did he build the plant?
• "Slowly lights appear around town" and then the power plant is turned on? What is powering those slowly appearing lights?

From this information, we can estimate that sometime between 1892 and 1897, the city of Medina generated enough electricity to power lights around town.

In order to pin the date down more exactly, more research was needed.

Question #1- When did the Ohio Legislature pass the bill that enabled Medina City Council to try for the levy?
Judy Russell, the Legal Genealogist, is always blogging about tracking down the original laws. She makes it seem easy. It isn't. But...

In the online Journal of the Senate of the State of Ohio, Volume 89, page 372, I found this:

The bill was read 2 more times.
"Mr. Strock" is Mr. Charles Strock from Niles in Trumbull County, Ohio.

"Tuesday, March 15, 1892.
H.B. No. 612 - Mr Strock (by request): To authorize the council of any incorporated village in the state of Ohio, which contained at the last federal census of 1890, or which at any subsequent federal census may contain a population of not less that two thousand and seventy-three nor more that two thousand and eighty-three, to issue bonds and levy a tax for the payment of the same and interest thereon for the purchase and erection of an electric light plant."

WHAT? Did you catch that wording? " population of not less that two thousand and seventy-three nor more that two thousand and eighty-three". That is a very specific size population, with only a 10 person difference. According to Wikipedia, Medina's population in 1890? 2,073. This bill, while not naming Medina specifically, targeted the town especially.

The bill passed the following day.

Question #2 - So, by mid March of 1892, Medina was permitted to put a levy on the ballot. But when did the election take place?

To find this information, I have been scouring the Medina Gazette newspaper microfilm. I have not found the date of the election, but I did find some more information.

Medina Gazette 12 May 1892, page 4.

So the Village Council had approved the tax by mid-May 1892, but Mr. Herman Holmes was not happy with their decision and was filing a lawsuit to stop them from going forward. Mr. Holmes was a Civil War Veteran and Medina business man. His main complaint was that the proposed plant was too expensive. Oh, and he didn't want any poles put on his East Liberty Street property.

Since the common pleas court only met every quarter, progress on the suit was very slow...

Medina Gazette 21 July 1892, page 1

So now we have narrowed the date that Medina got electricity from 1893 to 1897...

And just like the court case, this blog will have to be continued to allow time for more research...

SOURCES:

Beyond the Storefronts http://www.medinasquare.org/

Historical Highlights of Medina
Medina County: Coming of Age
Sanborn Fire Insurance Maps
Wikipedia - Medina census population
Journal of the Senate of the State of Ohio, Volume 89
Medina County Gazette